Summary:
The Court of Appeal in Abuja has strongly criticized the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), accusing it of partisanship and irresponsible behavior in a Friday judgment on a Bauchi State House of Assembly election appeal.
The court declared the election of the Speaker, Abubakar Suleiman, null and void, citing evidence of inconclusiveness. INEC was further directed to conduct a supplementary poll in 10 polling units within 90 days.
The court expressed dismay at INEC’s conduct, emphasizing the need for the electoral body to act as an unbiased umpire and fulfill its role responsibly.
Key Points:
- The Court of Appeal accused INEC of partisanship and irresponsible conduct in a Bauchi State House of Assembly election appeal.
- The court nullified the election of the Speaker, Abubakar Suleiman, declaring it inconclusive and voiding his Certificate of Return.
- INEC was directed to conduct a supplementary poll in 10 polling units within 90 days.
- The court awarded a cost of N500,000 against INEC.
- The judgment followed an appeal by the APC candidate, Khalid Abdulmalik-Ningi, dissatisfied with the initial election results.
- The court criticized INEC for disowning documents it had issued and certified, urging the electoral body to act as an unbiased umpire.
- The decision highlighted the significance of certified INEC documents in proving alleged non-compliance with electoral laws.
Background:
The Bauchi State House of Assembly election held on March 18 saw Abubakar Suleiman declared the winner by INEC with 16,866 votes. The APC candidate, Khalid Abdulmalik-Ningi, contested the results, alleging over-voting and corrupt practices. The tribunal initially dismissed the petition, but the Court of Appeal overturned this decision, emphasizing the probative value of the certified INEC documents presented by the appellant. The court’s judgment underscores the importance of INEC’s responsibility as an unbiased election umpire.
Conclusion:
The Appeal Court’s decision serves as a significant rebuke to INEC, emphasizing the vital role the electoral body plays in ensuring fair and transparent elections. The nullification of the Bauchi Speaker’s election highlights the court’s commitment to upholding electoral integrity and holding institutions accountable for their actions.